ConStruction Law  Mechanic's Leins 

Los Angeles Mechanic's Liens Attorney

Contractors, subcontractors, design professionals and suppliers can put a mechanic's lien on a property when a bill remains unpaid. Until the lien is satisfied, it can affect the owner of the property in many adverse ways, preventing the owner from selling the property and even resulting in foreclosure.

Legal Help for Filing Mechanic's Liens

We have been advising contractors, subcontractors and suppliers on their rights regarding mechanic's liens for over 40 years. It is often a necessary last resort when seeking payment to protect your business. Because of the complexity of construction laws and regulations regarding the filing, enforcement and satisfaction of mechanic's liens, it is in your best interest to contact an experienced construction lawyer to learn more about them before you file.

In order to successfully file a mechanic's lien, you must:

  • Be currently licensed — if your license lapsed at any point during the project, you will not be eligible to file a lien
  • Have a legitimate cause to file a mechanic's lien — if you cannot substantiate your claim, you can in turn be sued
  • File a lawsuit

As a construction professional, you must adhere to a timetable and a formal set of requirements to file a preliminary notice. Additionally, there is a limit on the number of days allowed to record the mechanic's lien. (Click here for an easy to understand chart).

How to Remove a Mechanic Lien in California

What happens when a mechanic's lien is filed against your property? If it is a valid claim, the consequences of not paying can be dire, affecting your ability to get a loan or sell your property — or if you cannot or will not pay the lien, your property could even be foreclosed.

What happens, though, if you feel the mechanic's lien is unsubstantiated? A claim may be unsubstantiated if:

  • Work was not completed
  • Supplies/materials were not included
  • Work was defective or unnecessarily delayed
  • The contractor was not properly licensed
  • The claimed work includes items beyond services that improved the project, such as delay damages
  • Other clauses in the contract were not met

If a mechanics lien has not been perfected by the filing of a lawsuit or extension of the lien period within 90 days, an owner can petition the court to have the lien removed. In addition, if the lien seeks compensation for items other than services not properly the subject of a mechanic's lien, such as delay damages, an owner can file a motion requesting that the court remove the lien. Lambert v. Superior Court (MacEwen) (1991) 228 Cal.App. 3d 383.

If you have had a mechanic's lien filed against you, it is imperative that you contact an experienced construction attorney right away. In addition to possible breach of contract issues, contractors have a timeline which they are required to follow. Their failure to do so will invalidate any mechanic's lien claim they filed against your property.

The Utility of the Bonded Stop Work Notice on Private Projects

On a private project in California, an additional procedure that can be used to protect rights is to serve a bonded stop notice (renamed as a bonded stop work notice effective July 1, 2012) on the construction lender. This notice must be completed within the time period that any mechanics lien could be recorded against the project. Needless to say, the longer the wait, the less funds will be held by the lender due to the disbursements being made as the job progresses.

To accomplish this procedure, the claimant or its insurance agent could contact a bonding company. The company should be advised that you desire to obtain a bond for a stop work notice on a private work. They will ask you various questions concerning the project and will have you complete an application for a bond. Please have them send the original bond directly to your office. Upon receipt, an attorney can prepare a stop notice and serve it on the branch where the construction funds are being held. It is critical to serve the right branch or else it can result in a stop notice being defective. In some factual circumstances, the filing of the stop work notice may be the only means to recover money. For example, if a contractor is insolvent, and the owner files bankruptcy, the bonded stop notice may still get the claimant paid. Many contractors have a practice of serving a stop work notice on a lending institution when the notice is not bonded. Most lending institutions will simply ignore such a notice and they are not required to pay attention to it absent the bond.

While provisions limiting liability have been upheld in construction contracts, provisions which seek to eliminate liability for negligence or willful misconduct are void as against public policy. See California Civil Code section 2782.

Mechanics Lien Release Bond

The mechanics lien release bond stands in the place of the mechanics lien. California Civil Code section 8424 provides one method for removing a mechanic's lien. It permits an owner who disputes a lien to release the property from the lien by posting a surety bond equal to 125 percent the amount of the claim. Once the release bond is recorded, the owner of the property is released from the mechanics lien cause of action and the contractor must file a supplemental complaint adding a cause of action on the release bond against the principal of the bond and the bond surety. See e.g., Fontana Paving, Inc. v. Hedley Brothers(1995). 38 Cal. App.4th 146, 151.

Mechanic's lien release bonds may be enforced by the summary procedure provided for in California Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.440. Grade-Way Construction v. Golden Eagle Ins. Co, 13 C.A.4th 826 (1993).

Public Works Projects

There are no mechanics lien rights on public projects. Construction professionals may only protect themselves through public stop notices and payment bonds. Serving a public works stop notice is a similar procedure to the private stop notice referenced above, but no bond need be obtained.

Notice of Nonresponsibility

A Notice of Nonresponsibility is the mechanism for a property owner to release its interest in property after receiving a preliminary notice from a contractor who has an agreement with the property owner's tenant. A Notice of Nonresponsibility generally states that the owner will not be responsible for the alteration, repairs, material or labor used. If the Notice of Nonresponsibility was recorded and posted within 10 days of the owner learning of the work of improvement, the notice insulates the owner from any liability for foreclosure of a mechanic's lien. California Civil Code Section 3094.

However, if the notice was filed too early (i.e., before construction commenced) or too late, the lienor may have lien rights against the owner even though it posted and recorded the Notice of Nonresponsibility. For example, there must be actual construction, not intended construction. A premature notice is ineffective to relieve an owner from liability. Arthur B. Siri, Inc. v. Bridges, 189 Cal. App.2d 599 (1961 ); Hayward Lbr. & Inv. Co. v. Orondo Mines, 34 Cal. App.2d 697.

The lienor can also proceed against the owner, despite the Notice, if the owner required the restaurant to perform the improvements by the terms of the lease. In such a case, the lessor is a participating owner and an agency relationship is implied by law. Howard S. Wright Construction Co. v. Superior Court (BBIC Investors), 106 Cal. App.4th 314 (2003). The fact that the lease did not require any improvements is not determinative. Where the lease is let for a particular purpose and the purpose cannot be effected without the tenant making improvements, the landlord is deemed to be a participating owner. Howard S. Wright Construction Co. v. Superior Court (BBIC Investors), supra. Similarly, if the owner knows of the work being performed, but fails to serve and record a Notice of Nonresponsibility, the prime contractor can avoid the need to serve a preliminary notice. Civil Code ' 3129; Halspar v. LaBarthe (1965) 238 Cal. App.2d 897; Benson Electric v. Hale Bros (1966) 246 Cal. App.2d 686.

New Form for Mechanic's Liens, Effective January 1, 2011

Assembly Bill 457 has made extensive changes to the form of the mechanic's lien in California, effective January 1, 2011. The Assembly Bill has made major changes to California Civil Code Section 3084, the main statute describing the form of mechanic's liens. It also requires service of the lien on the owner prior to recordation. Effective July 1, 2012, former section 3804 was recodified in Civil Code Section 8416.Need Help With a Mechanic's Lien?

We have over 40 years of experience in assisting construction professionals and property owners throughout Southern California regarding mechanic's liens. Call (888) 577-1518 to learn more.

Client Testimonials
  • “We highly appreciate having his advocacy on our side.”

    - Roie Maor
  • “Lovett got it right away and was spot-on. He got right to the point and encouraged me not to go off on tangents. He managed me well throughout a difficult case. Lovett was fair/reasonable in the fees ...”

    - Dr. Pamela Morton
  • “Steve Lovett has been our go to business attorney since 1980. That in itself says a lot about how we feel regarding his guidance and consistently strong service. When we call for advice he usually ...”

    - Richard B. Lehman, CID, EnvironeticsĀ®
  • “I had a very positive experience with Steven Lovett. He took the extra step to resolve the issues I had and, in a shorter than anticipated time; my ordeal was over. I would highly recommend him to any ...”

    - J. Timbol, William's Paving
  • “Mr. Lovett has been my counsel for over ten years. He has been representing and consulting my firm in construction and real estate matters and me. During that time Mr. Lovett has successfully ...”

    - Rafi Sharon, Globe Remodeling Inc.