ConStruction Law  Architects and Engineers - Conditioning Payment by Owner: Pay When Paid Clauses 

Conditioning Payment by Owner

Pay When Paid Clauses in California

California courts have refused to enforce provisions requiring that a contractor be paid by the owner before a subcontractor can be paid by the contractor. In Yamanishi v. Bleily and Collishaw, Inc., the court of appeals refused to enforce the following provision as a condition of payment:

"Contractor agrees...[t]o pay to the subcontractor upon receipt of each payment received from the Owner the portion of said payment allowed to Contractor on account of Subcontractor's work, to the extent of Sub-contractor's interest therein less any percentage retained under said General Contract."

The court refused to interpret this provision as requiring payment by the owner before the subcontractor could get paid. Rather, the court held that this provision merely stated the times at which the subcontractor would ordinarily be entitled to progress payments for its work. The court recognized that an interpretation should be avoided which would make a contract unusual, extraordinary, harsh or inequitable.

Furthermore, a contract should not place one party at the mercy of the other. The court rejected the general contractor's interpretation which would postpone payments earned by a subcontractor, itself without fault, until the dispute between the contractor and owner was resolved, perhaps months or even years later. This 1972 case removed a common ploy by general contractors which prevented subcontractors from being paid until the general was paid.

Client Testimonials
  • “We highly appreciate having his advocacy on our side.”

    - Roie Maor
  • “Lovett got it right away and was spot-on. He got right to the point and encouraged me not to go off on tangents. He managed me well throughout a difficult case. Lovett was fair/reasonable in the fees ...”

    - Dr. Pamela Morton
  • “Steve Lovett has been our go to business attorney since 1980. That in itself says a lot about how we feel regarding his guidance and consistently strong service. When we call for advice he usually ...”

    - Richard B. Lehman, CID, EnvironeticsĀ®
  • “I had a very positive experience with Steven Lovett. He took the extra step to resolve the issues I had and, in a shorter than anticipated time; my ordeal was over. I would highly recommend him to any ...”

    - J. Timbol, William's Paving
  • “Mr. Lovett has been my counsel for over ten years. He has been representing and consulting my firm in construction and real estate matters and me. During that time Mr. Lovett has successfully ...”

    - Rafi Sharon, Globe Remodeling Inc.